Renovating and retrofitting for high-performance buildings

Renovating and retrofitting for high-performance buildings

It’s a question that comes up on most campuses. How do we create a modern, sustainable living environment within the confines of the spaces we currently have available?

Whether your student life facilities date back to 1960 or 1890, transforming them into high-performance buildings – ones that meet student expectations, accommodate desired programming, consume less energy, employ green design elements and are cost-effective to build and operate — isn’t a pipe dream. Successful renovation projects on a number of campuses are proving that, with the right approach, it can be done. Here’s how:

Know your consumers’ priorities

While the role of a campus living environment— developing community and developing students— hasn’t changed, the expectations that students bring to campus certainly has. Rick Kenzler, University Architect at Illinois State University, says recent renovations of seven residences and three dining centers were driven by feedback from potential freshmen. “Many of these students had never shared a bedroom, and in some cases, had never shared a bathroom with parents or siblings. They were consumers in the strongest sense of the word, looking for the best value.” Offering suite-style housing choices and marketplace dining experiences was a clear priority.

Allow form to follow function

It’s tempting to see renovations as systems replacement projects. But high-performance buildings require bigger picture thinking, says Eddie Hull, Dean of Residence Life and Executive Director of Housing Services at Duke University. What are the implications of the programming changes you need to make? Will this require new spaces, redesigned spaces or changes in building capacity? Then you can determine impacts on handicapped access, evaluate building systems and introduce sustainability initiatives through product selection, building envelope and landscaping.

Make a real commitment

At Duke, which has pledged to be carbon neutral by 2020 and recently opened its LEED Platinum Smart Home residence, a university-wide commitment to model sustainable practices overcame resistance to change. That commitment goes beyond design and construction guidelines. It involves engaging field staff in the review and selection of systems and products being considered for capital projects and providing training and equipment needed to effectively manage and maintain renovated facilities. In addition, student life and housing leaders must champion their projects, says Hull. “If you don’t believe in what you need a project to accomplish, how can you expect anyone else to support it?”

Balance contingencies

With existing facilities, it’s hard to know what you’re going to encounter inside the walls. Contingency planning requires a sensitive balance between pre-project investigation to calculate potential costs and not being so conservative that you leave money on the table that could have been used to achieve your desired program

Don’t solve every problem

When beginning a renovation project, it’s easy to fall into the trap of trying to solve every problem ever documented in the building. Stick to the primary goals of your project and address the infrastructure issues related to that goal. Along the way, you’ll identify the smaller issues that may be solved with maintenance funds down the road, says Kenzler.

Tighten up your schedule

Faster decision-making is often stronger decision-making, says Molly Ranz Calhoun, Assistant Vice President and Director of the Office of Student Life at The Ohio State University. “More time and money don’t necessarily mean better decisions,” she says. “When you have longer schedules, you can take longer to make decisions and second-guess everything.” Learn from what you’ve done before, take new risks and move forward expeditiously.

Don’t rush design

Across the board, campus leaders agree that solid, well thought out design is critical to success. Even on the tightest schedule, spending the time to get the design right can make or break the cost-effectiveness of the process and the finished building. It can also mean the difference between a building that performs well today and one that is also flexible enough to meet future needs.

Weigh green options carefully

On a current residence hall renovation at The Ohio State, Ranz Calhoun says her team looked carefully at ways to meet campus guidelines for 30% reduction in energy usage over 2004 levels for all residence halls and achieve LEED Silver status. “Replacing the windows we installed in 1998 would take 150 years to pay off, and we would be putting those windows into a landfill. We had to ask, ‘Is this the right thing to do?’” The university kept the windows and conserved energy through insulating the building envelope and employing a 50% geothermal heating and cooling solution.

Harness students’ passions

Engage students in innovative solutions, advises Von Stange, Ed.D., Assistant Vice President for Student Services and Director of Housing and Dining at the University of Iowa. Often, students aren’t aware of sustainable features in the buildings they’re using, or how to reduce their personal energy use, because universities aren’t communicating that. Effective communication not only educates students about sustainability, it allows student enthusiasm and creativity to push a campus to achieve more within its facilities.




The historic renovation of Ferrell Hall at Benedictine College created a 21st century residence hall for 152 juniors and seniors. The original character of the building was maintained. Existing wood floors were salvaged and refinished. The original stone and brick arches were cleaned and highlighted in the new layout.

Can this building be saved?

On many campuses, the answer is yes. But a careful evaluation of your facilities means weighing a number of competing factors. Consider the following questions before green-lighting a demolition:

Programming. Is the building design truly capable of serving the desired programming and occupancy, now and into the future? Once it’s renovated, will your new building be flexible enough to be redesigned to meet new program needs 40 or 50 years down the road?

Structure. Is this building structurally sound enough to last? Are there significant structural or space limitations? If you can’t save the building, can you salvage building materials for new construction? At The Ohio State University, Habitat for Humanity was called in to deconstruct the existing student union and materials were salvaged for the charity’s projects as well as for use in the new Ohio Union.

Hazardous materials. Do you know what’s hiding in this building? In many older facilities, removal of asbestos, lead and other hazardous materials adds cost

and time to the project. A conservative estimate of these costs must weigh into your decision making. This is not the place to underestimate.

Balancing occupancy with schedule. Can you feasibly work on the building while it’s occupied? How quickly will you need to bring the facility on-line? And what will you do with the users in the event that you need to empty the building?

The 70% rule. Is it going to cost you less than 70% of the cost of new construction to renovate the building? If so, what a bargain. For example, at the University of Iowa, converting a campus hotel into student housing meant addressing moisture issues, replacing HVAC systems, adding insulation and other high-cost measures. Yet at 50% the cost of a brand new residence hall, the renovation, which will also provide students with desirable private bathrooms, is a wise expenditure, says Von Stange.

Look for Us

ACUHO–I Annual Conference & Expo
June 26–29, 2010 | Austin, Texas

From Lava Lamps to iPhones: Updating 60’s Dorms into 21st Century Living/Learning Centers
Interest Session 7 | June 29, 2010 | 1:45pm

Frankie Minor,
University of Missouri–Columbia

Diana Robertson,
University of Kansas

Ginny Arthur,
Iowa State University

Nadia Zhiri,
Treanor Architects

To update your information please click here

Southeast Missouri State University Cape Girardeau, M0 308-Beds / Pod-Style Semi-Suites